Doctor Jenn Prosser is an emergency medicine physician and toxicologist passionate about poisons. She’s the creator and host of the Pick Your Poison Podcast. She’s published on topics including cocaine, meth, bath salts, fentanyl, sports supplements, and body packing of drugs for internal concealment. Her work has been recognized nationally and internationally.
Pick Your Poison is a fast-paced, interactive podcast about poisons, toxins, mayhem, and murder, spanning time from ancient history to pop culture. Make the wrong choice, and your patient won’t survive the podcast!

What inspired you to start a podcast? Poisons!! I love telling the stories of poisons and sharing everything I’ve learned, from medicine to murder, ancient history to cutting-edge science, and everything in between. I love solving the mystery of what poisoned a patient and sharing the excitement with listeners.
Where do you write? Anywhere. I write a script for each show. I want to cram in as many fascinating facts as possible, but I also want to keep episodes short and concise. The script provides balance, so I don’t ramble on forever. Locations include the desk in my office, hotels, cafes, trains, planes, beaches, hair salons, and waiting rooms, to name a few. My favorite? On a quiet redeye flight with noise-canceling headphones. It feels like a silent cocoon with no distractions. As for distractions…
Do you allow distractions when writing? Yes! I’d love to be more disciplined, i.e., faster, but I’m continuously sucked into rabbit holes and pulled down meandering paths during research. Like Alice in Wonderland, sometimes. It yields many fascinating facts, but sadly, it wastes lots of valuable time. I’ve discovered things like which celebrity has drug-inspired artwork in their home, what moonshine has to do with NASCAR, what medicine comes from a bean used in African witchcraft trials, and which plant, now used as a drug, might’ve been used by Medea to kill her children in ancient Greece.
What is your writing/research process? I always follow the same framework. First, the topic is something I feel inspired to share and discuss. I try to vary episodes between natural toxins, chemicals, pharmaceuticals, etc. Second, the invention of a fictional patient with symptoms and presentation representative of the poison. Then, research using medical resources like toxicology textbooks or journal articles to review scientific details like mechanisms of action, treatment, etc. (Want to hear more about my research methods? I’m giving a talk on this topic for SinC Central Virginia on October 10, 7 pm EST – RSVP). Then it’s time for my favorite part, the rabbit holes and meandering paths. I scour the internet for interesting historical facts, mythological stories, pop culture references, crazy criminals, and other random facts.
What settings do you use for the podcast? Generally, the Emergency Department. I start each case as a mystery, allowing the listener to solve the case as a toxicologist or ER doctor would. Every case is fictional but based in real life. I love learning this way myself. I can remember patients and cases much more easily than long recitations of facts. I mix up the settings. For example, I’ve included tropical destinations with vacations gone wrong thanks to culinary misadventures or encounters with local wildlife.
What obstacles do you encounter? One challenging element is balancing content. I have highly knowledgeable medical professionals listening and those with no medical background, because who doesn’t love hearing about poisons? I try to walk a fine line straight down the middle with something for everyone without losing anyone in the weeds. Another issue is medicine, and toxicology especially, doesn’t always have all the answers. I wish we had an antidote for every poison, but that’s not the case. We aren’t allowed to conduct randomized, controlled clinical trials by poisoning half of the patients to see what treatment works best. Instead of glossing over these issues, I try to involve listeners in these real medical dilemmas.
What’s the most challenging part? Time!! I balance the podcast with family and a real job. For each episode, I research the topic, write the script, record the podcast, edit it, publish it, and try – emphasis on try- to promote via social media. Most days, I could use more than 24 hours!
Want to find out more? Check out the podcast!
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/pick-your-poison/id1686838151
https://open.spotify.com/show/2saYRMCoQEMneVKxJ94pjf?si=bfa792e2c30a4149
Social Media and Contact Info:
Website: Pickpoison.com
X: @pickpoison1
Instagram: @pickpoison1
Email: pickpoison1@gmail.com
Writers Clubs:
Sisters in Crime (Main, Guppies, NorCal)
Pick Your Poison is a treasure trove for authors who write about poisonings. Well Done!
Thanks Pamela!!
Great to hear Pamela. Thanks so much!!
Wow, you sound like one busy lady doctor. Back when I was a cop, i used to know a lot of emergency room personnel. We had one physician, Dr. Bernie we called him, who would show up on high risk calls ( a small baby chocking, a gunshot victim, etc.). I always told him he should write a book. I’m glad you’re sharing your expertise, and thanks for your service.
Thank you Michael!
I love your podcast, Jen. Thanks for sharing your enthusiasm for poisons with us. I completely relate to your take on distractions—I’ve tried to eliminate them but I find those deep dives into sometimes offbeat research do enrich my writing.
Victoria – it’s such a fine line between discovery and distraction!
I thoroughly enjoy your podcast, Jen! I’m not well-versed in medicine, but I can follow along and I occasionally can guess the right answer to your questions. (I guess my patient will live. Maybe!)
Meredith – glad your patient will live – lol.
Thank you for sharing. I often see emails from writers wanting to know about specific poisons. I now have a professional to refer them to.
Excellent Steve. Thanks!
I’m so glad you’re getting the attention for your podcast. It is so well deserved. How about turning all the podcasts on poison you’ve done into a book … a reference book for those of us to have on our workdesks?
Hi Glenda – love this idea. Has been percolating in my brain….
Love researching poisons! Great to learn about your podcast. I used poison in House of Dads. Bella donna 🙂